YouTube vs Grey: A Ballad of Accidental Suspension

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 24 November 2019
  • Join my email list: www.cgpgrey.com/email
    Follow me on Twitter: cgpgrey

Comments • 4 259

  • David Wittberg
    David Wittberg  23 jam yang lalu

    Google is evil, we MUST find an alternative, meanwhile, educate yourself, use different browsers and search engines, like duck and Mozilla. Don't give Google all your info.

    • seeriu ciihy
      seeriu ciihy  Hari Yang lalu

      CGP Grey: I'm not a Bot Also CGP Grey: Sleeps with Borg regeneration technology under pillow.

      • fukckgooogle
        fukckgooogle  Hari Yang lalu

        when will we get Grey vs. Self-Indulgence

        • Dwight Clough
          Dwight Clough  Hari Yang lalu

          whoa!

          • thyrza vogelaar
            thyrza vogelaar  Hari Yang lalu

            I Have gmail

            • seeriu ciihy
              seeriu ciihy  Hari Yang lalu

              Migrate to bitchute?

              • ceerw buty
                ceerw buty  Hari Yang lalu

                youtube and twitter "we want everyone to have their voices heard... except those of you who we dont like"

                • unyeckenerd
                  unyeckenerd  Hari Yang lalu

                  0:44 weird flex but ok

                  • Shonda Barta
                    Shonda Barta  Hari Yang lalu

                    it's amazing what youtube can let happen.

                    • Jake Williams
                      Jake Williams  2 hari yang lalu

                      C'mon, you're not that stupid, are you? There was no accident. There was no algorithmic hiccup. What happened to you was a warning. It was a robot book-sniffing dog in Fahrenheit 451 being sent to your front door.

                      • ceerw buty
                        ceerw buty  Hari Yang lalu

                        So Hermes told you they cancelled your account? Zeus couldn’t get off his ass and tell you himself?!

                        • SuperGikes
                          SuperGikes  2 hari yang lalu

                          What?! No RSS feed?

                          • matthew3785
                            matthew3785  2 hari yang lalu

                            They thought you were a fake because you have been uploading too much

                            • Dan Douglas
                              Dan Douglas  2 hari yang lalu

                              Isn't this music from a cyriak video?

                              • Robert Vassallo
                                Robert Vassallo  2 hari yang lalu

                                Love the marketing aspect here, this was a fun and worth while ask. Awesome work!

                                • yaliso gioouy
                                  yaliso gioouy  2 hari yang lalu

                                  This is the future Kafka was trying to warn us about!

                                  • Andres Cabezas
                                    Andres Cabezas  2 hari yang lalu

                                    At this point in history, I would go beyond calling IDclips's algorithmic suspensions "accidental" and would call them "negliglent" instead.

                                    • Andres Cabezas
                                      Andres Cabezas  2 hari yang lalu

                                      Especially the "no prior warning" part of these suspensions.

                                      • Giggino Gigetto
                                        Giggino Gigetto  2 hari yang lalu

                                        A bee ! There was a BEEEEE !!! In the window 0:01

                                        • Dorian Alexandru
                                          Dorian Alexandru  2 hari yang lalu

                                          idclips.com/video/Q2ZnJ5wrzG0/video.html SUBSCRIBE,I GIVE BACK

                                          • Dorian Alexandru
                                            Dorian Alexandru  2 hari yang lalu

                                            yaliso gioouy thanks

                                            • yaliso gioouy
                                              yaliso gioouy  2 hari yang lalu

                                              Should also try BitChute, a torrent based IDclips like clone.

                                              • Econael
                                                Econael  2 hari yang lalu

                                                I prefer RSS. Have you got an RSS feed?

                                                • Kentucky Bruce
                                                  Kentucky Bruce  2 hari yang lalu

                                                  Congratulations, you made it to the home page of IDclips

                                                  • Ulisses Buffon
                                                    Ulisses Buffon  3 hari yang lalu

                                                    Migrate to bitchute?

                                                    • first last
                                                      first last  3 hari yang lalu

                                                      Gmail is trying to overturn emails? Huh? Gmail is a email service, you know. One I don't even usually use.

                                                      • bssni touir
                                                        bssni touir  3 hari yang lalu

                                                        CGP Grey: I'm not a Bot Also CGP Grey: Sleeps with Borg regeneration technology under pillow.

                                                        • Jacelyn Wong
                                                          Jacelyn Wong  3 hari yang lalu

                                                          F*ck you

                                                          • Shay071705
                                                            Shay071705  3 hari yang lalu

                                                            So Hermes told you they cancelled your account? Zeus couldn’t get off his ass and tell you himself?!

                                                            • Das Ganon
                                                              Das Ganon  3 hari yang lalu

                                                              Nice job hiding the Borg charger under your pillow

                                                              • bssni touir
                                                                bssni touir  3 hari yang lalu

                                                                That explains why I have only been notifiednow

                                                                • Dave Sturniolo
                                                                  Dave Sturniolo  3 hari yang lalu

                                                                  BOT like? OK for games but not Social Media? Hmmm... Confused. :(

                                                                  • Mulan
                                                                    Mulan  3 hari yang lalu

                                                                    CGP, you bring to much podcast stuff I'm not interested in in your email list, so I unsubscribed from it years ago.

                                                                    • Brandon Troost
                                                                      Brandon Troost  3 hari yang lalu

                                                                      1:27 could have sworn that he was going to say pewdiepie

                                                                      • bandie9101
                                                                        bandie9101  3 hari yang lalu

                                                                        very good briefing about the all-speading fury of vendor locking on the Internet

                                                                        • sehhi vooty
                                                                          sehhi vooty  3 hari yang lalu

                                                                          This is why we need decentralized platforms. Like steemit

                                                                          • VR VR
                                                                            VR VR  3 hari yang lalu

                                                                            Oh! No, I haven't gotten notifications of your new videos in some time.

                                                                            • Yoshimasa Chong
                                                                              Yoshimasa Chong  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                              Uploads orgignal content Gets banned for being yourself. Really putting "broadcasting yourself" out the window yt.

                                                                              • D. Dillon Duffield
                                                                                D. Dillon Duffield  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                Should also try BitChute, a torrent based IDclips like clone.

                                                                                • David Potter
                                                                                  David Potter  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                  You angered the Gods of Political Correctness and Wokeness by saying "Indians" > "Native Americans" and ye was pushed

                                                                                  • ManicDee
                                                                                    ManicDee  Hari Yang lalu

                                                                                    David Potter yeah, wouldn’t be surprised to find that this was a brigade action.

                                                                                    • Shawn Carroll
                                                                                      Shawn Carroll  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                      So here we have a constitutional right, "In Suits at common law, where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved..." that the Supreme Court held Congress can abrogate, under the US Arbitration Acton of 1925 and subsequent case law. For those not recognizing the quoted text, it's the beginning of the 7th Amendment. As a quick, originalist reminder, "Agreements to arbitrate were not enforceable at common law, traced back to dictum by Lord Coke in Vynor’s Case, 8 Co. Rep. 81b, 77 Eng. Rep. 597 (1609), that agreements to arbitrate were revocable by either party." That's why a true libetarian is not particularly fond of either political party. Unless you (whisper it very quietly) believe we should (please don't choke as the heresy passes your lips) think we should REGULATE big mega corps that want the advantage of benefiting from laws that protect intellectual property, enforcement proceedings against scofflaws, and felony prosecution of scammers who abuse the trust necessary for free markets to prosper...

                                                                                      • cgr4217
                                                                                        cgr4217  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                        I hear with bitchute you can have it automatically copy whatever you upload to your IDclips channel

                                                                                        • The Lone Wanderer
                                                                                          The Lone Wanderer  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                          Recently discovered your channel. Just wanted to say thank you for the work you do. There are not a lot of channels like yours out there in the matrix

                                                                                          • Jasmeet Singh
                                                                                            Jasmeet Singh  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                            lol. it was just a bug dude. Relax 😂

                                                                                            • TheOtherGuys2
                                                                                              TheOtherGuys2  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                              I think suspensions, demonetizations, bans, copyright strikes, and similar things should be decided by a jury of peers, instead of by an algorithm. If there's a concern over a channel or video, then an algorithm can select, say, 13 other users of a similar stature, (like say, between 4 and 4.5 million subs), and ask them to review the content and determine if it violates policies or laws or anything. Not only would this reduce false flags getting through, it would help familiarize people with the process, and make it so that everyone depends on everyone else. You wouldn't vote against a channel just because you don't like them, because tomorrow they could be voting on your issue. Probably not a perfect system, but better than having your channel suddenly suspended for the crime of following all the rules. Incidentally, I think that's how Minds.com handles it, and they've just launched a partners program to help creators earn money on their platform.

                                                                                              • gtoss chddy
                                                                                                gtoss chddy  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                chance that the word "colonizer" or "colonial" would be used to describe you or your content. They probably didn't even finish the video.

                                                                                                • Rodic Delete
                                                                                                  Rodic Delete  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                  This is the future Kafka was trying to warn us about!

                                                                                                  • Harvey Davenport
                                                                                                    Harvey Davenport  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                    That explains why I have only been notifiednow

                                                                                                    • gtoss chddy
                                                                                                      gtoss chddy  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                      case was then reviewed by a similarly biased employee who knew you'd complain and get it back in a day or two because the complaints were baseless. Basically you got

                                                                                                      • shivangoes
                                                                                                        shivangoes  4 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                        CGP Grey: I'm not a Bot Also CGP Grey: Sleeps with Borg regeneration technology under pillow.

                                                                                                        • gtoss chddy
                                                                                                          gtoss chddy  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                          Annnd COPPA isn't the only problem, apparently

                                                                                                          • Tyson
                                                                                                            Tyson  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                            CGP Grey: [Manages to upload 4 videos in 1 month] Me: Yay! IDclips: Banned!

                                                                                                            • Trileche de la Rosa
                                                                                                              Trileche de la Rosa  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                              STTOP BOT

                                                                                                              • gtoss chddy
                                                                                                                gtoss chddy  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                This is why you should move to Bitchute, Grey.

                                                                                                                • daryl graham
                                                                                                                  daryl graham  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                  This is why we need decentralized platforms. Like steemit

                                                                                                                  • Ch0kes
                                                                                                                    Ch0kes  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                    So... You sleep with an strange device right under your head? Cool

                                                                                                                    • browsingfloor62
                                                                                                                      browsingfloor62  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                      Why are you sleeping on a borg... thing

                                                                                                                      • Daniel Jackowitz
                                                                                                                        Daniel Jackowitz  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                        Publisher, not a platform. Deciding what gets put up means publisher.

                                                                                                                        • Carlos Agredano
                                                                                                                          Carlos Agredano  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                          Who also heard this on the Hello Internet podcast.

                                                                                                                          • foopyu nooui
                                                                                                                            foopyu nooui  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                            Annnd COPPA isn't the only problem, apparently

                                                                                                                            • Warp Zone
                                                                                                                              Warp Zone  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                              I vote we stop calling it "the algorithm" and start calling it "the career-ending robot with capricious human handlers."

                                                                                                                              • Warp Zone
                                                                                                                                Warp Zone  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                Wait tell us more about the sacrifice to the gods. How do we appease the youtube algorithms with these sacrifices?

                                                                                                                                • Lure
                                                                                                                                  Lure  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                  CGP Grey's ancestors anecdotally invented religion

                                                                                                                                  • foopyu nooui
                                                                                                                                    foopyu nooui  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                    (I think) 0:56 Violation letter 1:04 CGP Grey as a bot 2:18 A pile of iPads

                                                                                                                                    • Axel Gust
                                                                                                                                      Axel Gust  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                      I only just got a notification for this... 6 days late.

                                                                                                                                      • Suiseisexy
                                                                                                                                        Suiseisexy  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                        Oh, I'm pretty sure I know what you "did". You're white, you're male and you're not specifically selling a progressive viewpoint. You dared to be white and make a video about another race, which presumably is the last thing you uploaded before this happened. So what happened is "activists" pressed a button on the video to complain repeatedly, your case was then reviewed by a similarly biased employee who knew you'd complain and get it back in a day or two because the complaints were baseless. Basically you got burger king foot lettuce'd by some itchy trigger finger wacko at Google just for how you "sound", they probably wouldn't even defend doing so, but if they did there's about a 99.9% chance that the word "colonizer" or "colonial" would be used to describe you or your content. They probably didn't even finish the video.

                                                                                                                                        • Mathieu Martin
                                                                                                                                          Mathieu Martin  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                          You guys on IDclips have it easy. Want a super arcane and arbitrary system that depends on the whims of a potentially psychopathic dictator? Try Second Life.

                                                                                                                                          • frankda4
                                                                                                                                            frankda4  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                            You should email us an update about how many more people joined the email list since this video.

                                                                                                                                            • Ed
                                                                                                                                              Ed  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                              Utube's excuse for blocking your account is BS. Some SF, pink haired, frump didn't like the Indian video because that hurt it's feelings.

                                                                                                                                              • Alsadius
                                                                                                                                                Alsadius  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                                I'm sort of astonished that these services don't offer a "Let me deal with humans" option - pay $100/month or something, and you're guaranteed the right to talk to a human when shit happens. It'd only be used by big creators and businesses, really, but it'd eliminate this whole "arbitrary and capricious" feel to the whole process. Amazon sellers, IDclips creators, big Facebook pages, all of that. You'd all happily pay for bullshit insurance, they'd even make a profit on it, and it's not like they need to give you the algorithms or anything.

                                                                                                                                                • The Generalissimo
                                                                                                                                                  The Generalissimo  5 hari yang lalu

                                                                                                                                                  This is why you should move to Bitchute, Grey.